In this article
Renting and buying both cost money, but they cost it in different ways. Buying means a down payment, closing costs, a mortgage, taxes, insurance and maintenance, plus selling costs at the end, while building equity and benefiting from any rise in the home's value. Renting means a monthly payment with no ownership, but it leaves your down payment and monthly savings free to invest.
This calculator compares the two paths by net worth after the number of years you plan to stay. It does not declare a universal winner, because the answer depends on your numbers.
How the rent vs buy calculator works
Both people start with the same cash. The buyer uses it for the down payment and closing costs. The renter invests it. Each month the calculator tracks:
The buyer - Pays the mortgage (principal and interest), property tax, insurance, maintenance and HOA dues. Taxes and maintenance grow as the home's value grows. - Builds equity as the loan balance falls and the home's value changes. - At the end, net worth = sale price − selling costs − remaining loan, plus any money the buyer invested because owning cost less than renting in some months.
The renter - Pays rent and renters insurance, which rise each year by the rent increase you enter. - Invests the starting cash at your assumed return, and also invests any month where renting costs less than owning. - If owning costs less than renting in a given month, the buyer invests that difference instead.
The result is the difference in net worth at your chosen year. A positive number means buying is ahead, and a negative number means renting is ahead.
What the calculator leaves out
The tool does not include the mortgage interest deduction, the home sale gain exclusion, moving costs, or the emotional and practical value of stability. These can matter:
- Tax deductions only help if your itemized deductions exceed the standard deduction ($16,100 for a single filer and $32,200 for joint filers in 2026), which many homeowners do not reach.
- The home sale exclusion lets a homeowner exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 for married couples filing jointly) if they owned and lived in the home for at least 2 of the last 5 years. That makes appreciation more valuable to the buyer than the model shows.
- Taxes on the renter's investments are partly captured by the "after-tax" return input.
Worked example: a $400,000 home or $2,200 rent
Default assumptions: 20% down, a 30-year mortgage at 7.24%, 1% property tax, $1,800 a year of insurance, 1% of value a year for maintenance, 3% closing costs, 6% selling costs, 3% a year home price growth, $2,200 monthly rent rising 3% a year, and a 5% after-tax return on invested money.
- Cost to own in year 1: $2,999 a month
- Cost to rent in year 1: $2,220 a month
- Cash needed to buy: $92,000 (down payment plus closing costs)
- Net worth after 7 years: buy $169,689 versus rent $195,915
- Break-even: year 13
Under these assumptions, renting is ahead by $26,227 after seven years, and buying catches up in year 13. Closing and selling costs are large, so buying needs a long stay to win unless the mortgage rate is low or prices rise quickly.
How long you stay matters
| Years you stay | Net worth if you buy | Net worth if you rent | Buy minus rent |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | $100,889 | $135,416 | -$34,527 |
| 5 | $133,906 | $165,316 | -$31,410 |
| 7 | $169,689 | $195,915 | -$26,227 |
| 10 | $229,182 | $242,962 | -$13,780 |
| 15 | $346,752 | $323,598 | $23,154 |
| 20 | $501,323 | $413,173 | $88,150 |
Selling costs of 6% on a $400,000 home are about $24,000, and closing costs are $12,000. Those $36,000 of transaction costs need time to be absorbed by equity growth and by the rent you avoid.
Which assumptions matter most
Net worth difference after 10 years (buy minus rent) as home price growth and investment returns change. Everything else stays at the default values.
| Home price growth \ Investment return | 3% | 5% | 7% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1% a year | -$57,551 | -$93,114 | -$134,788 |
| 3% a year | $22,460 | -$13,780 | -$56,186 |
| 5% a year | $118,483 | $81,513 | $38,318 |
Positive numbers favor buying and negative numbers favor renting. Moving across the grid changes the answer by tens of thousands of dollars. That is why no calculator can tell you with certainty which option is better: the future growth rate of your local housing market and of your investments are unknowns.
How the rent level changes it
The price-to-rent relationship in your market is the other big driver. Here is the 10-year result for the same $400,000 home at different rents:
| Monthly rent for a comparable home | Buy minus rent after 10 years | Break-even |
|---|---|---|
| $1,500 | -$136,189 | Not within 30 years |
| $2,000 | -$48,754 | Year 22 |
| $2,500 | $38,681 | Year 7 |
| $3,000 | $126,117 | Year 4 |
| $3,500 | $213,552 | Year 3 |
What each input means
Home price, down payment, rate and term. These set the loan and the monthly payment. Use a lender quote for the rate.
Property tax and insurance. Local rates vary widely, so use numbers from listings or your county assessor.
Maintenance. A common planning range is around 1% of the home's value a year, but older homes may cost more. The calculator grows it with the home's value.
Closing and selling costs. Buying costs often run a few percent of the price, and selling with agent commissions costs more. Defaults are 3% and 6%.
Home price growth. The most uncertain input. Long-run national averages are not a forecast for your city, so test low and high values.
Rent and rent growth. Use the rent for a similar home, not a smaller one. Compare size, location and condition fairly.
Investment return. The after-tax return you expect on money that is not tied up in the house. Use a conservative number. Higher assumed returns favor renting.
Years you will stay. If you might move in three years, buying will rarely win.
How to read the results
The headline compares net worth at your chosen year. The "Break-even" card tells you when buying pulls ahead after selling costs, if it does within 30 years. The year-by-year table shows how the gap changes. Look for the gap shrinking or flipping sign, since it shows how sensitive the answer is.
Also compare the monthly cost cards. If owning costs far more per month than renting, buying is a bigger strain on your budget, even if it wins on net worth later. And remember that this comparison counts money only. Stability, the freedom to renovate, risk of repairs and the ability to move easily have value that a calculator cannot price.
Common mistakes
- Comparing a house with a smaller apartment. The rent entered should be for a comparable home.
- Ignoring transaction costs. Closing and selling costs are part of the cost of buying, especially for short stays.
- Counting only the mortgage payment. Taxes, insurance and maintenance are also costs of owning.
- Assuming a hot market will continue. Past appreciation does not set the future.
- Forgetting what the down payment could do elsewhere. The money has other uses, even if the return is uncertain.
- Treating the result as a recommendation. It shows trade-offs under assumptions, not a guarantee.
Frequently asked questions
Is it better to rent or buy?
It depends on how long you will stay, home price growth, the mortgage rate, rent levels and what you would do with the money you do not spend on a down payment. The calculator lets you test your own numbers.
How long do you need to stay in a home to make buying worthwhile?
There is no fixed number. With the default assumptions the break-even is in year 13, but cheaper rates, higher rents or faster price growth shorten it, and the opposite lengthens it. Many people use a three-to-five-year minimum as a rule of thumb, which is not a promise.
Does the calculator include the mortgage interest deduction?
No. The deduction only helps if you itemize, and most households take the standard deduction. If you expect to itemize, your results would tilt a little toward buying.
Why does renting come out ahead in the example?
With a 7.24% mortgage rate, high transaction costs and an assumed investment return of 5%, the renter's invested savings grow faster than the buyer's equity over seven years. Lower rates or higher home price growth would change that.
Should I include the down payment's investment return?
Yes, that is the main opportunity cost of buying. The calculator invests the renter's starting cash at the return you enter, and it treats that return as after tax.
What about the home sale tax exclusion?
If you own and live in the home for 2 of the last 5 years, you can exclude up to $250,000 of gain ($500,000 on a joint return). The calculator does not model it, so large gains favor buying more than the results show.
Sources
Disclaimer: This page is for educational purposes only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Figures are estimates based on the assumptions shown. See our full disclaimer and editorial policy.