Renting vs Buying a Home
The choice between renting and buying is often framed as "throwing money away" versus building equity, but both sides have costs that are easy to miss. Buying has taxes, insurance, maintenance, closing and selling costs. Renting has no equity, but it keeps cash free for other uses. This guide compares them with a worked example and explains the break-even idea.
- Buying builds equity but has costs renters don't pay: interest, property tax, insurance, maintenance, closing costs and selling costs.
- The longer you stay, the more likely buying wins, because closing and selling costs are spread over more years. Staying only a few years often favors renting.
- A fair comparison includes what you could earn on the down payment and on the monthly difference if you rent.
- The result depends heavily on the rent, price, rate, appreciation and your time horizon. Run your own numbers.
In this article
What each side costs
Owning: mortgage interest, property taxes, homeowners insurance, maintenance and repairs (a common planning range is about 1 percent of the home's value a year), HOA dues, closing costs when buying (often 2 to 5 percent) and selling costs (often around 6 percent with agent fees), plus the lost return on the down payment.
Renting: rent, renters insurance, annual rent increases and moving costs. You don't pay for repairs, property taxes or selling.
Principal repaid is not a cost: it builds equity. Interest, taxes, insurance, maintenance and transaction costs are the real ownership costs.
A worked comparison
Home price $400,000, 20 percent down, a 30-year mortgage at 7.24% (the recent Freddie Mac average), property tax 1.1 percent of value, insurance $1,800 a year, maintenance 1 percent, 3 percent closing costs and 6 percent selling costs. Home prices grow 3 percent a year. A comparable rental costs $2,400 a month with 3 percent increases a year, and the renter invests the down payment and monthly savings at 5 percent after tax. All of these are assumptions that you should replace with local numbers.
| Years you stay | Net worth if you buy | Net worth if you rent | Ahead |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | $100,889 | $128,800 | Renting by $27,911 |
| 7 | $169,689 | $177,848 | Renting by $8,160 |
| 12 | $273,208 | $237,228 | Buying by $35,980 |
"Net worth" counts the home equity left after selling costs for the buyer, and the invested down payment, closing costs and monthly savings for the renter, so higher is better. On these assumptions the break-even is year 9: before then renting comes out ahead because buying and selling costs have not yet been recovered. Change the rent, price or rate and the break-even year changes. Use the rent vs buy calculator with local numbers.
The break-even idea
Break-even is the number of years after which buying becomes cheaper than renting. In many markets it falls between five and ten years, but it can be shorter where rents are high relative to prices and longer where prices are high relative to rents. A common rule of thumb compares the price-to-rent ratio, the home's price divided by a year of comparable rent, but it is only a screening tool.
Non-financial factors
| Buying may suit you if | Renting may suit you if |
|---|---|
| You plan to stay many years | You may move within a few years |
| You want stability and control of the space | You value flexibility |
| You have a solid emergency fund after the down payment | The down payment would drain your savings |
| You can handle repair surprises | You don't want maintenance responsibility |
| Your job and income are stable | Your income is uncertain |
Don't forget the risks of buying
- Price risk. Home prices can fall, particularly if you must sell in a downturn.
- Liquidity. Equity is hard to access without selling or borrowing.
- Concentration. A home is a large single asset.
- Surprise costs. Roof, heating and plumbing can cost thousands. See hidden costs of homeownership.
- Rate and tax changes.
Don't forget the risks of renting
- Rent increases and non-renewal
- No equity to build or borrow against
- Less control over the property
- Rising rents over decades compared to a fixed-rate mortgage payment
Questions to ask yourself
- How long will I realistically stay?
- Can I put at least 10 to 20 percent down and still hold an emergency fund?
- Would the full monthly cost, including taxes, insurance and maintenance, fit my budget? See how much house can I afford.
- What could I earn if I invested the down payment instead?
- What is the local price-to-rent ratio?
If you decide to buy, read how to buy a house.
Common mistakes
- Comparing rent to the mortgage payment only.
- Ignoring maintenance, taxes and insurance.
- Assuming prices always rise.
- Buying for a short stay.
- Using all your savings for the down payment.
- Treating rent as wasted while treating interest and taxes as investment.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to rent or buy?
It depends on local prices, rent, rates and how long you stay. Over a short time, renting is usually cheaper; over a long time, buying often is.
How long do I need to stay to make buying worthwhile?
Often five years or more, but it varies by market.
Is rent money wasted?
Rent pays for housing, just as interest, taxes and maintenance do for owners. Only the principal part of a mortgage payment builds equity.
Should I rent and invest the difference?
That can work if you actually invest consistently. The calculator assumes you do.
What about taxes?
Owners who itemize may deduct mortgage interest and property taxes within limits. Many households take the standard deduction. See standard vs itemized deduction.
Sources
Disclaimer: This page is for educational purposes only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Figures are estimates based on the assumptions shown. See our full disclaimer and editorial policy.