New vs Used Car
A new car offers a warranty, the latest safety features and known history. A used car costs less up front and avoids the steepest early drop in value. Which is cheaper over time depends on the price gap, financing, repairs and how long you keep it. This guide compares the costs and gives a decision framework.
- New cars typically lose value fastest in the first years, so much of the saving on a used car comes from someone else absorbing that drop.
- Used car loans usually carry higher interest rates than new car loans, and used cars tend to need more repairs, both of which reduce the savings.
- Compare total cost over the period you will own the car: purchase price, interest, depreciation, repairs, insurance and fuel.
- Certified pre-owned cars sit between the two, with inspections and extended warranties at higher prices than other used cars.
In this article
What drives the cost difference
- Depreciation. The drop in value from the day you buy to the day you sell. It is usually the largest single cost of owning a car, and it is steepest early.
- Financing. Loan rates differ by new or used, credit and term. See how car loans work.
- Repairs and maintenance. New cars have warranties; used cars may not.
- Insurance. Typically higher for a more expensive car. See how to lower car insurance.
- Taxes and fees. Sales tax and registration are often based on price.
- Reliability and features. Newer models may have better safety and fuel efficiency.
An illustrative five-year comparison
Assumptions: a new car for $36,000 financed at 6.0% and a comparable used model for $24,000 financed at 7.5%, both for 5 years, with no down payment and ignoring tax and fees. Resale after five years is assumed at 55 percent of the purchase price for the new car and 65 percent for the used car. Repairs not covered by warranty are assumed at $2,500 for the new car and $6,000 for the used one. These are assumptions for illustration, not averages.
| New | Used | |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | $36,000 | $24,000 |
| Monthly payment | $695.98 | $480.91 |
| Interest over the loan | $5,759 | $4,855 |
| Value after 5 years | $19,800 | $15,600 |
| Lost to depreciation | $16,200 | $8,400 |
| Repairs not covered | $2,500 | $6,000 |
| Depreciation + interest + repairs | $24,459 | $19,255 |
Under these assumptions the used car costs less over five years, but the gap is smaller than the price difference of $12,000 suggests. Change the inputs and the result can flip. For example, if the used car needs $10,000 in repairs, the gap narrows further. Test your own numbers with the auto loan calculator.
Advantages of buying new
- Manufacturer warranty and fewer early repairs
- Latest safety and fuel-efficiency features
- Choice of exact options and color
- Possible promotional financing. See 0% APR financing vs rebate
- Known history
Advantages of buying used
- Lower price and a smaller loan
- Less depreciation over the time you own it
- Lower insurance and registration in some cases
- More choice of models in your price range
Certified pre-owned (CPO)
CPO vehicles are late-model used cars that pass a manufacturer or dealer inspection and come with an extended warranty. They cost more than non-certified cars and less than new. Compare what the warranty covers and for how long, who pays for repairs and whether the premium over a similar non-certified car is more than the warranty is worth.
Buying a used car safely
- Get a vehicle history report using the vehicle identification number (VIN) to check for accidents, title problems and odometer issues.
- Have an independent mechanic inspect it before purchase.
- Check for open recalls using the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's lookup.
- Test drive on different roads.
- Check the title and make sure the seller owns the car.
- Review the FTC Used Car Rule buyers guide displayed on dealer cars, which states whether the car comes with a warranty or is sold as-is.
Deciding
| If you... | Lean toward |
|---|---|
| Keep cars for 10 or more years | New, since you capture the full life of the car |
| Replace every 3 to 5 years | Used, to avoid the steepest depreciation |
| Have limited cash for repairs | New or CPO, with a warranty |
| Are on a tight budget | Used, within your payment limits |
| Value specific safety features | Newer models, new or lightly used |
Whatever you choose, keep the total cost within your budget. A common guideline is to keep total car costs, including insurance, to a modest share of take-home pay. See how much car can I afford and true cost of owning a car.
Common mistakes
- Comparing only the sticker prices.
- Skipping the inspection on a used car.
- Ignoring interest rate differences.
- Stretching the loan term to make an expensive car fit.
- Rolling negative equity from a trade-in into a new loan.
- Paying for add-ons you don't need.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to buy new or used?
Usually used, because of lower depreciation, but higher repair costs and loan rates can narrow the gap.
How many miles is too many on a used car?
Condition and maintenance history matter more than the number alone. Have a mechanic inspect it.
Is certified pre-owned worth it?
Sometimes, if the warranty and inspection are worth the premium. Compare costs.
Should I lease instead?
Leasing is a separate decision. See car lease vs buy.
Does a used car have higher interest rates?
Often yes, because lenders see used vehicles as higher risk. Compare quotes.
Sources
Disclaimer: This page is for educational purposes only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Figures are estimates based on the assumptions shown. See our full disclaimer and editorial policy.