Car Lease vs Buy
A lease is a long-term rental: you pay for the part of the car's value you use during the term, plus a finance charge and fees. A loan pays for the whole car. This guide explains how lease payments are calculated, compares leasing and buying with an example and lists the rules that catch people out.
- A lease payment covers depreciation (the drop in value during the lease) plus a finance charge. You return the car at the end with no equity.
- Leases usually have lower monthly payments than loans on the same car, but you pay for as long as you drive and have nothing to show at the end.
- Mileage caps, wear charges and early termination fees can add large costs. Read the contract.
- Leasing tends to suit people who want a new car every few years and drive moderate mileage. Buying tends to suit people who keep cars long.
In this article
How lease payments are calculated
Three inputs matter:
- Capitalized cost: the price the lease is based on, after negotiation and including fees you roll in. It is the equivalent of the selling price, and it is negotiable.
- Residual value: the car's expected value at the end, set by the lessor as a percentage of the manufacturer's suggested retail price.
- Money factor: the finance charge. Multiply by 2,400 to approximate an APR.
Monthly payment = depreciation charge + rent charge, where
- depreciation charge = (capitalized cost − residual value) ÷ months
- rent charge = (capitalized cost + residual value) × money factor
Sales tax and fees are applied on top, depending on the state.
Worked example
A $36,000 capitalized cost, a 58% residual ($20,880), 36 months and a money factor equal to a 6.0% APR (0.0025):
| Part | Calculation | Monthly |
|---|---|---|
| Depreciation | ($36,000 − $20,880) ÷ 36 | $420.00 |
| Rent charge | ($36,000 + $20,880) × 0.0025 | $142.20 |
| Lease payment before tax | $562.20 |
Buying the same $36,000 car with a 60-month loan at 6.0% would cost about $695.98 a month. All figures are illustrative.
Three years later
| Lease | Buy with a 60-month loan | |
|---|---|---|
| Payments made in 36 months | $20,239 | $25,055 |
| What you own | Nothing; return the car | A car with some equity (value minus loan balance) |
| Next step | Lease another car, buy it out or walk away | Keep driving payment-free after loan ends, or trade in |
A buyer is still paying after three years but owns an asset. A lessee has paid less but must start over. Over a very long period, a person who keeps buying cars and driving them for years after the loan ends usually pays less than someone who leases continuously, because leasing means making payments forever. Run your own comparison with the auto loan calculator.
Costs and rules to check in a lease
- Mileage limit. Common limits are 10,000 to 15,000 miles a year. Overage fees are charged per mile, often in the range of 10 to 30 cents. Estimate your real mileage first.
- Wear and tear. Dents, tire wear and interior damage beyond the contract's standard can be billed at turn-in.
- Disposition fee charged at the end if you return the car.
- Early termination. Ending a lease early can mean paying most or all of the remaining payments. Check the formula.
- Acquisition fee at the start, sometimes rolled into the payments.
- Down payment ("capitalized cost reduction"). Putting a lot down on a lease is risky: if the car is totaled or stolen, you may not get it back.
- Gap coverage. Many leases include it. If not, consider it.
- Insurance requirements. Lessors usually require higher liability limits and lower deductibles. See how to lower car insurance.
- Buyout price. The residual value plus fees if you want to keep the car.
When leasing may fit
- You want a new car every two to four years
- You drive a predictable, moderate number of miles
- You want lower monthly payments and warranty coverage throughout
- You use the car for business and can deduct lease costs (ask a tax professional; rules differ for personal and business use)
When buying may fit
- You keep cars for many years
- You drive a lot or have unpredictable mileage
- You want to customize the car
- You want to build equity and have no payment later
Negotiating a lease
- Negotiate the price (capitalized cost) first, as if you were buying.
- Ask for the money factor and compare with the lender's base rate.
- Check the residual value. A higher residual lowers the payment.
- Review all fees in the contract.
- Compare total cost, including down payment, over the term.
Common mistakes
- Focusing only on the monthly payment.
- Underestimating mileage.
- Not negotiating the capitalized cost.
- Large down payments on a lease.
- Ignoring end-of-lease charges.
- Leasing to afford a car beyond your budget. See how much car can I afford.
Frequently asked questions
Is leasing cheaper than buying?
Monthly, usually yes. Over many years, buying and keeping the car tends to cost less in total.
Can I buy my car at the end of the lease?
Often yes, for the residual value plus fees stated in the contract.
What happens if I go over the mileage limit?
You pay a per-mile fee at turn-in, as stated in your lease.
Does a lease affect my credit?
Applying causes a hard inquiry and the lease appears as an account on your credit report. On-time payments help. See how to build credit.
Can I lease with bad credit?
It's harder and costlier. Lessors usually want good credit.
Sources
Disclaimer: This page is for educational purposes only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Figures are estimates based on the assumptions shown. See our full disclaimer and editorial policy.