In this article
Both account types grow without yearly tax. The difference is when the tax bill arrives. With a traditional IRA or 401(k), you contribute before tax (or take a deduction), and you pay income tax on withdrawals. With a Roth, you contribute after tax, and qualified withdrawals are tax-free. This calculator compares them for the same out-of-pocket cost, so you can see which one leaves you with more money you can actually spend.
How the Roth vs traditional calculator works
The idea is to compare the accounts on equal terms. Each year you set aside the same amount from your take-home pay. Here is what happens next:
- Roth. The full amount goes into the account. Nothing is deducted, so $6,000 of take-home pay is $6,000 in the account.
- Traditional. Because the contribution is pre-tax, the same take-home cost buys a bigger contribution. The calculator divides your amount by (1 minus your tax rate now). At a 24% rate, $6,000 of take-home pay becomes $7,895 in the account.
- Growth. Both balances grow at the same annual return for the same number of years.
- Tax at withdrawal. The traditional balance is reduced by your expected tax rate in retirement. The Roth balance is not reduced.
- Comparison. The calculator shows both after-tax values and the difference.
One assumption matters here. The extra pre-tax money in the traditional account is the tax you saved. If you spent that tax saving instead of investing it, the Roth would come out ahead. The comparison assumes you invest it, by making the larger contribution.
Worked example: 24% now, 18% later
Suppose you can set aside $6,000 of take-home pay a year for 30 years, you earn 7% a year, and you are in the 24% bracket now but expect to be in the 18% range in retirement.
| Roth | Traditional | |
|---|---|---|
| Contribution each year | $6,000 | $7,895 |
| Balance after 30 years | $606,438 | $797,945 |
| Tax at withdrawal (18%) | $0 | $143,630 |
| Value after tax | $606,438 | $654,315 |
The traditional account wins by $47,877. The reason is simple: you avoided tax at 24% going in and paid only 18% coming out.
Who wins at different retirement tax rates
Everything else stays the same in this table (a 24% rate now, $6,000 a year, 30 years, 7%). Only the tax rate in retirement changes.
| Tax rate in retirement | Roth, after tax | Traditional, after tax | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0% | $606,438 | $797,945 | Traditional |
| 10% | $606,438 | $718,151 | Traditional |
| 15% | $606,438 | $678,253 | Traditional |
| 18% | $606,438 | $654,315 | Traditional |
| 22% | $606,438 | $622,397 | Traditional |
| 24% | $606,438 | $606,438 | Tie |
| 26% | $606,438 | $590,479 | Roth |
| 30% | $606,438 | $558,562 | Roth |
| 35% | $606,438 | $518,664 | Roth |
At 24% the two are exactly equal. That is the break-even point, and it is always the same as your rate now. Below it, traditional wins. Above it, Roth wins. The size of the gap grows with the number of years, because the balance has more time to grow.
Which tax rate should you use?
Use your marginal rate, which is the tax on your next dollar of income. It is not your average rate. A person with a $70,000 salary does not pay 22% on all of it, but the next dollar they earn or save is taxed at 22%, and that is the rate a deduction would avoid.
Here are marginal rates for a single filer in 2026, using the standard deduction of $16,100:
| Income | Taxable income | Federal tax | Average rate | Marginal rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $30,000 | $13,900 | $1,420 | 4.7% | 12% |
| $50,000 | $33,900 | $3,820 | 7.6% | 12% |
| $70,000 | $53,900 | $6,570 | 9.4% | 22% |
| $90,000 | $73,900 | $10,970 | 12.2% | 22% |
| $130,000 | $113,900 | $19,934 | 15.3% | 24% |
| $200,000 | $183,900 | $36,734 | 18.4% | 24% |
Add your state income tax rate if your state has one. Use the federal income tax calculator or the tax bracket calculator to find your exact bracket.
The tax rate in retirement is a guess, and a hard one. Your income will probably come from several places: Social Security, withdrawals from traditional accounts, interest and dividends. Many people end up in a lower bracket than during their peak earning years, but not everyone does, and tax laws can change.
When a Roth tends to make sense
- You are early in your career. Your income, and your bracket, may be low now and higher later.
- You expect higher taxes in retirement, either because your income will rise or because you think tax rates will go up.
- You want tax-free flexibility. Qualified Roth withdrawals are not part of your taxable income, so they do not push up the income that decides how much of your Social Security is taxed. The IRS says up to 85% of benefits can be taxable depending on your other income.
- You may be near the Medicare surcharge. In 2026, single filers with income above $109,000 (joint filers above $218,000) pay an income-related surcharge on Medicare premiums. Tax-free Roth withdrawals can help you stay below it.
- You want no required minimum distributions. The original owner of a Roth IRA never has to withdraw. See the RMD calculator for the rules that apply to other accounts.
- You want to leave tax-free money to heirs.
When a traditional account tends to make sense
- You are in a high bracket now. The deduction is worth more at 32% than at 12%.
- You expect a lower bracket in retirement. That is the classic case for the pre-tax route.
- You need to lower your taxable income this year, for example to qualify for a credit that phases out at higher incomes.
- You are over the Roth IRA income limit. In 2026 a single filer cannot contribute directly at $168,000 of MAGI or more. See the Roth IRA calculator.
A traditional IRA deduction can be limited if you or your spouse are covered by a workplace plan. For 2026 the deduction for a single filer covered by a plan phases out between $81,000 and $91,000, and for a married couple filing jointly where the contributor is covered, between $129,000 and $149,000. Workplace 401(k) contributions are not subject to those limits.
Roth 401(k) or traditional 401(k)?
The same logic applies. Many employers offer both. The 2026 employee limit of $24,500 is shared between them, so you can split your contributions. Starting in 2026, employees who earned more than $150,000 in FICA wages in the previous year must make their catch-up contributions (the extra amount allowed at 50 and over) as Roth contributions. Roth 401(k) accounts also do not have required minimum distributions for the owner. The 401(k) calculator shows how much a workplace plan could grow.
You do not have to pick one. Some savers use traditional accounts for part of their savings and Roth accounts for the rest, which spreads the tax risk across both.
What this comparison leaves out
- Future tax changes. If tax rates rise or fall, the result changes. Splitting between account types reduces that risk.
- State taxes. Include them in your rates if they apply. Some people move to a state with a lower or no income tax in retirement.
- Employer match. Matching contributions are often pre-tax, which is a good reason to understand both types.
- Unequal limits. A Roth contribution of $24,500 is worth more than a traditional contribution of the same size, because you pay the tax on the Roth money from your own pocket. If you are maxing out an account, the Roth effectively shelters more.
- How you will actually take money out. Most people draw from several accounts, so a single "rate in retirement" is a simplification.
Common mistakes
- Using your average rate. The rate that matters is the marginal rate, and it is usually higher.
- Forgetting to invest the tax savings. The traditional account only wins if the money you save in tax goes to work too.
- Assuming you will be in a lower bracket. Check it. A large traditional balance can push your retirement income higher than you expect.
- Believing it is all or nothing. Using both account types is a reasonable plan.
- Ignoring the income limit. A Roth IRA is not available for direct contributions above the phase-out range, but a Roth 401(k) is.
Frequently asked questions
Is a Roth or a traditional account better?
Neither is better in general. If your tax rate will be higher when you withdraw, a Roth wins. If it will be lower, a traditional account wins. If it is the same, the two end up equal. The calculator shows the result for your numbers.
Can I contribute to both a Roth and a traditional IRA?
Yes, but the yearly limit is shared. For 2026 the total across all your IRAs is $7,500, or $8,600 if you are 50 or older.
Which tax rate should I enter?
Enter your marginal rate, federal plus state. For your rate in retirement, think about your likely income from all sources, not just the account you are comparing.
Do Roth accounts have required minimum distributions?
Not for the original owner of a Roth IRA, and since 2024 not for the owner of a designated Roth account in a workplace plan. Traditional IRAs and 401(k)s do.
What if tax rates go up in the future?
Then the Roth looks better, since you paid at today's lower rates. If rates fall, the traditional account looks better. Nobody knows which, so many people hold both types.
Does this work for a 401(k)?
Yes. The math is the same for a Roth 401(k) and a traditional 401(k). The difference is that the employer match, if any, is separate from this comparison.
Sources
- IRS Topic 451: Individual retirement arrangements
- IRS Publication 590-B: Distributions from IRAs
- IRS: Retirement plan and IRA required minimum distributions FAQs
- IRS Publication 915: Social Security and equivalent railroad retirement benefits
- IRS, 2026 tax inflation adjustments (IR-2025-103). Figures as of October 9, 2025
- IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32. Figures as of October 9, 2025
- IRS Topic 751. Figures as of January 1, 2026
- SSA, 2026 COLA fact sheet. Figures as of October 24, 2025
- IRS Topic 560. Figures as of January 1, 2026
- IRS Notice 2025-67 (2026 retirement plan limits). Figures as of November 13, 2025
- SSA, Medicare premiums. Figures as of October 13, 2026
- IRS Notice 2025-67. Figures as of October 13, 2026
Disclaimer: This page is for educational purposes only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Figures are estimates based on the assumptions shown. See our full disclaimer and editorial policy.