Should I Refinance My Mortgage?

A refinance can lower your payment, but it also has a price. This guide shows how to find the break-even point, what changes the answer and what to ask lenders.

Updated October 13, 202610 min readBy FinTools USA Editorial TeamChecked against official sourcesHow we review
Key takeaways
  • A refinance pays off only if you keep the new loan longer than the break-even point. Divide your closing costs by your monthly savings to find it.
  • In the example below, a $300,000 balance with 25 years left falls from 8.09% to the Freddie Mac average of 7.24%. The payment drops $167 a month. With $6,000 of costs, the break-even point is about 36 months.
  • A small rate drop can take years to pay back, and a rate at or above your current rate never does. Your current rate matters as much as today's rate.
  • Starting a new 30-year loan can lower the payment while raising the total interest you pay. Compare the totals, not just the payment.
  • Ask several lenders for a Loan Estimate on the same day, and check your loan for a prepayment penalty first.
In this article
  1. What a refinance is
  2. The break-even test
  3. How much the rate drop matters
  4. Your current rate matters as much as today's rate
  5. The term trap: starting over at 30 years
  6. Pay the costs now or roll them into the loan
  7. How long you keep the home changes everything
  8. Points and lender credits
  9. A prepayment penalty can erase the savings
  10. Cash-out refinancing
  11. How to shop for a refinance
  12. When refinancing usually does not make sense
  13. Common mistakes
  14. Frequently asked questions
  15. Sources

A refinance is a new loan that pays off your old one. It makes sense when the savings add up to more than the cost of getting the new loan before you move or refinance again. This guide gives you a simple test, then shows how the rate, the term, the closing costs and the time you stay change the result.

What a refinance is

The CFPB defines a mortgage refinance as taking out a new loan to pay off and replace your old loan. The new loan can have a different rate, a different term or a different balance. People usually refinance for one of four reasons:

  • A lower rate. The goal is a smaller payment or less total interest.
  • A shorter term. Moving from a 30-year loan to a 15-year loan raises the payment but cuts the interest. The 15-year vs 30-year guide shows the trade-off.
  • A safer loan type. Some borrowers swap an adjustable rate for a fixed rate so the payment stops changing.
  • Cash. A cash-out refinance borrows more than you owe, and the extra comes to you as cash. It is covered further down.

Each new loan comes with closing costs. The CFPB describes them as all of the costs you pay at closing, such as origination charges, appraisal fees, credit report costs and title insurance fees. Those costs are the price of the refinance. The closing costs guide explains the line items.

The break-even test

The test has two steps.

  1. Find your monthly savings. Subtract the new payment of principal and interest from your current payment.
  2. Divide. Closing costs divided by monthly savings gives the number of months it takes to earn the costs back.

If you expect to keep the loan longer than that, the refinance saves money. If you will sell or refinance again sooner, it loses money.

The closing costs in this example are an assumption, not a quote. Your Loan Estimate shows the real number. The refinance calculator runs this test with your own balance, rate and costs.

How much the rate drop matters

The size of the drop decides how long the payback takes. The table keeps the same loan and the same $6,000 of costs, and changes only the new rate.

Rate drop New rate New payment Monthly saving Break-even Net after 7 years
0.25 points 7.84% $2,284 $50 10 years 1 month -$723
0.50 points 7.59% $2,235 $99 5 years 1 month $4,542
0.75 points 7.34% $2,186 $148 3 years 5 months $9,796
1.00 points 7.09% $2,138 $196 2 years 7 months $15,037
1.50 points 6.59% $2,043 $291 1 year 9 months $25,478
2.00 points 6.09% $1,949 $384 1 year 4 months $35,861

A drop of a quarter point takes years to pay back, and over 7 years it may not pay back at all. A drop of a full point or more shortens the wait a great deal. There is no single rule that works for every loan, because the answer depends on your balance, your costs and how long you stay. That is why the break-even math is more reliable than a rule of thumb.

Your current rate matters as much as today's rate

Today's average rate is only half of the question. The other half is the rate you have now. The table uses a new rate of 7.24%, the Freddie Mac average of October 29, 2026, and changes the rate on your existing $300,000 loan.

Your current rate Current payment New payment Monthly change Result
9.24% $2,567 $2,166 -$401 Pays back in 1 year 3 months
8.24% $2,363 $2,166 -$197 Pays back in 2 years 6 months
7.74% $2,264 $2,166 -$98 Pays back in 5 years 2 months
7.49% $2,215 $2,166 -$49 Pays back in 10 years 4 months
7.24% $2,166 $2,166 No change No payback
6.24% $1,977 $2,166 +$189 No payback
5.24% $1,796 $2,166 +$371 No payback

If your rate is already below the market, a rate-and-term refinance raises your payment, so the reason to do it would have to be something other than the rate. In the Freddie Mac survey of October 29, 2026, the 30-year average was 7.24%, compared with 6.17% a year earlier. If you locked a lower rate than the average, keeping your loan is usually the cheaper path.

The CFPB points to the Freddie Mac averages as a way to get an idea of the rates you might be offered while you shop around. Your own offer can be higher or lower. Check current mortgage rates for the weekly numbers and what shapes your quote.

The term trap: starting over at 30 years

Many refinances start a fresh 30-year loan. That lowers the payment even when the rate stays the same, because the balance is spread over more months. It also gives the lender more years of interest. The table compares the same $300,000 balance at 7.24% with different terms. Your current loan is the starting point: $300,000 at 8.09% with 25 years left.

Loan Monthly payment Total interest Years of payments
Keep your current loan $2,333 $400,009 25
New 30-year loan at 7.24% $2,044 $436,018 30
New 25-year loan at 7.24% $2,166 $349,946 25
New 20-year loan at 7.24% $2,369 $268,635 20
New 15-year loan at 7.24% $2,737 $192,642 15

Closing costs are not in the interest totals. The 30-year row has the lowest payment, but it adds five more years of payments to the schedule. Shorter terms raise the payment and cut the interest. You can get both a lower payment and a shorter payoff only when the rate drops by a lot. If you take a 30-year loan for the low payment, you can still make extra payments toward principal. The extra mortgage payment calculator shows how much interest that saves.

Pay the costs now or roll them into the loan

Most lenders let you add the closing costs to the new balance, so you pay nothing at the table. That helps cash flow but costs more over time, because you pay interest on the added amount. Using the first example:

Pay costs at closing Roll costs into the loan
New loan amount $300,000 $306,000
New monthly payment $2,166 $2,210
Monthly saving $167 $124
Break-even 3 years 4 years 1 month
Net after 7 years $11,894 $9,031

Rolling in the costs leaves you with less cash needed on closing day but with a smaller monthly saving and a longer wait to break even.

How long you keep the home changes everything

The same refinance can be a good deal or a bad one, depending on when you leave. The table shows the net result for the first example at different stay lengths. A negative number means you would have been better off keeping the old loan.

Years you keep the home Net savings from refinancing
1 -$3,447
2 -$887
3 $1,675
5 $6,799
7 $11,894
10 $19,392

If you might move in two or three years, a refinance with high costs rarely works. If you plan to stay a decade, even a modest drop can add up.

Points and lender credits

You can often trade cash now for a lower rate. The CFPB explains that points lower your interest rate in exchange for paying more at closing. One point equals 1% of the loan amount. Lender credits work the other way. They lower your closing costs in exchange for a higher rate, so a "no closing cost" refinance usually means a higher rate instead of a free loan.

The CFPB gives this example. On a $180,000 loan with a zero-point rate of 5.0%, paying 0.375 points ($675) lowers the rate to 4.875%. On a 30-year term that cuts the payment from $966 to $953, a saving of $14 a month. The $675 is earned back in about 49 months, or roughly 4.1 years. Points pay off only if you keep the loan longer than that.

The CFPB's advice for comparing offers is to ask each lender for the same amount of points or credits. It also warns that some lenders use the word "points" for any percentage-based upfront fee, even one that does not lower your rate. Always ask how a point changes the rate.

For taxes, the IRS says points paid to refinance a mortgage are generally deducted ratably over the term of the loan. That means you spread the deduction over the life of the new loan instead of taking it all in the first year.

A prepayment penalty can erase the savings

A prepayment penalty is a fee some lenders charge if you pay off all or part of your mortgage early. The CFPB says it typically applies only if you pay off the entire balance, such as when you sell or refinance, and usually within the first three or five years. Paying extra principal in small amounts normally does not trigger it.

Check your loan documents or ask your servicer before you apply. If a penalty applies, add it to the closing costs in the break-even test. If you are close to the end of the penalty period, waiting a few months may be cheaper.

Cash-out refinancing

A cash-out refinance replaces your loan with a larger one and pays you the difference. The CFPB defines home equity as what your property is worth minus what you owe on it, and equity is what makes cash-out possible. The cost is simple to estimate. Borrowing an extra $30,000 at 7.24% for 30 years adds $204 to your monthly payment, and if you keep the loan the whole term, it costs about $43,602 in interest. Your home secures the whole loan, so a missed payment puts the home at risk.

A cash-out refinance can make sense for a project that adds value or to replace costlier debt, but the payment lasts for decades while many purchases do not. Compare it with other ways to borrow before you decide. The credit card payoff calculator shows what the high-rate debt you want to replace is costing you.

How to shop for a refinance

  1. Gather your numbers. Write down your balance, rate, remaining years, monthly payment and any prepayment penalty.
  2. Check your equity. Estimate what your home is worth and subtract what you owe. The CFPB defines equity this way. Equity matters because, if the new loan is for 80% or less of the home's appraised value, PMI is generally not required.
  3. Ask several lenders for a Loan Estimate. The CFPB says interest rates can change daily, so a difference between two lenders could be a market change. Request the estimates on the same day if you can.
  4. Compare the items that matter. Look at the interest rate, the monthly payment, the cash to close and the fees that vary by lender. The CFPB tells borrowers to focus on the fees that vary by lender, such as origination charges and lender credits, rather than on taxes and insurance that the lender does not control.
  5. Use the five-year line. Page 3 of the Loan Estimate shows the "In 5 years" totals. Subtract the principal paid from the total paid to get the five-year cost of borrowing, and compare it across offers.
  6. Negotiate. The CFPB says your best bargaining chip is usually having Loan Estimates from other lenders in hand.
  7. Lock the rate. The CFPB says locks are typically available for 30, 45 or 60 days, and sometimes longer, and that it may be expensive to extend one if your closing needs more time. Ask what happens if closing is delayed.

When refinancing usually does not make sense

  • You may move soon. If you will leave before the break-even month, you lose money.
  • Your rate is already low. A new loan at a higher rate raises your payment.
  • The term resets and you are far into the loan. In the early years of a loan most of each payment is interest, so a fresh 30-year schedule starts that cycle again.
  • The costs are too large for the saving. A big drop in rate with high costs can still take years to pay back.
  • You need the cash only for spending. Borrowing against a home for short-lived purchases leaves the debt long after the item is gone.
  • A prepayment penalty applies. Wait until the period ends if the penalty is larger than the saving for the extra months.

Common mistakes

  1. Comparing only the monthly payment. A lower payment on a longer loan can cost more in total.
  2. Ignoring how long you will stay. The break-even month is the number that matters.
  3. Forgetting to count all the costs. Include points, a prepayment penalty and any rate lock extension.
  4. Taking one quote. The CFPB suggests comparing Loan Estimates because lenders price loans differently.
  5. Rolling in costs without checking the effect. It cuts cash due at closing, but it raises the balance you pay interest on.
Refinance CalculatorEnter your balance, rate and closing costs to find your break-even point.
Open the calculator

Frequently asked questions

How much lower does the rate need to be to refinance?

There is no fixed number. A drop of a quarter point can work for a large balance with low costs and a long stay, and a full point can fail if the costs are high and you leave soon. Use the break-even test with your own numbers. The table above shows how fast the payback improves as the drop grows.

How long should I stay in the home after refinancing?

At least until the break-even point, and preferably well past it. In the first example the refinance breaks even after about 36 months, so staying 7 years leaves you about $11,894 ahead. Staying one year leaves you behind.

Is a no-closing-cost refinance really free?

Usually not. The CFPB explains that lender credits lower your closing costs in exchange for a higher interest rate, so you pay through the rate instead of at closing. That can be a fair trade if you expect to keep the loan for a short time. Compare the monthly payment and the total cost with a version that has the costs paid up front.

Can I refinance if I have a prepayment penalty?

You can, but the penalty may apply. The CFPB says a prepayment penalty typically applies when you pay off the entire balance, including when you refinance, within a short window of usually three or five years. Read your loan terms and ask the servicer for the amount.

Should I refinance to remove mortgage insurance?

It can work. If your new loan is for 80% or less of your home's appraised value, PMI is generally not required on a conventional loan. FHA mortgage insurance on a loan with less than 10% down lasts for the life of the loan, so many FHA borrowers refinance once they have enough equity. Compare the saved premium with the closing costs, and see how to get rid of PMI for cheaper options.

Is a cash-out refinance a good way to pay off credit cards?

It can lower the interest rate on the debt, but it turns unsecured debt into debt secured by your home and stretches it over many years. If you run up the cards again, you end up with both. Compare the total cost, not just the monthly relief.

Are refinancing costs tax deductible?

Not as a general rule. The IRS says points paid to refinance a mortgage are generally deducted over the term of the loan. Costs such as appraisal and notary fees are not deductible as interest. Ask a tax professional how your situation is treated, and keep in mind that only people who itemize can deduct mortgage interest.

Sources

Disclaimer: This page is for educational purposes only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Figures are estimates based on the assumptions shown. See our full disclaimer and editorial policy.

Free calculators for this topic

Keep reading