Rebalancing Your Portfolio

Over time, the investments that grow fastest take up a larger share of your portfolio, which can leave you with more risk than you planned for. Rebalancing resets the mix. This guide explains why it matters, how often to do it, the main methods and how to avoid unnecessary taxes.

Updated October 14, 20264 min readBy FinTools USA Editorial TeamChecked against official sourcesHow we review
Key takeaways
  • Rebalancing means adjusting your holdings back to your target mix of stocks, bonds and other assets after market moves change the percentages.
  • Common approaches are calendar rebalancing (once or twice a year), threshold rebalancing (when an asset drifts by a set amount, such as 5 percentage points) or using new contributions to buy what is underweight.
  • In a taxable account, selling winners can create capital gains tax. Rebalancing inside IRAs and 401(k)s avoids that.
  • Target-date funds and many robo-advisors rebalance automatically.
In this article
  1. Why portfolios drift
  2. A worked example
  3. Methods of rebalancing
  4. How often should you rebalance
  5. Rebalancing and taxes
  6. Rebalancing in a 401(k)
  7. Does rebalancing improve returns?
  8. A simple rebalancing routine
  9. Common mistakes
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Sources

Why portfolios drift

Suppose you decide on 60% stocks and 40% bonds. If stocks rise faster than bonds for a few years, your stock share may grow to 70% or more. You now hold more risk than you chose, and a market decline will hurt more than you planned for. The opposite can happen too, after a stock decline leaves you underweight in stocks and potentially behind on growth.

Rebalancing is a way to keep your risk consistent with your plan. It does not aim to boost returns, though it can modestly affect them. The main purpose is to control risk. For more on setting the mix, see asset allocation by age and stocks vs bonds.

A worked example

You start with $100,000: 60% in a stock fund and 40% in a bond fund. After a year in which stocks gain 25% and bonds gain 3% (a hypothetical year), the portfolio looks like this:

Value Share of portfolio Target
Stocks $75,000 64.5% 60%
Bonds $41,200 35.5% 40%
Total $116,200 100% 100%

To get back to 60% stocks, you would move about $5,280 from stocks to bonds. The portfolio's total value does not change, but its risk does.

If you add money regularly, you could skip selling. Directing new contributions to bonds until the mix returns to target accomplishes the same thing without a sale.

Methods of rebalancing

Method How it works Pros Cons
Calendar Check on a set date, such as once a year Simple, predictable May rebalance when unnecessary, or miss large drifts
Threshold (bands) Rebalance when an asset class moves more than a set amount, like 5 percentage points from target Responds to actual drift Requires periodic monitoring
Hybrid Check on a schedule, and rebalance only if outside bands Balances effort and discipline Needs rules
Cash flow Direct new deposits and withdrawals to the underweight asset No selling, no taxes Slower if contributions are small relative to the portfolio
Automatic Done by a target-date fund or robo-advisor No effort Less control; check the fees

Research by large fund companies has found that moderate frequencies, such as annually or when allocations drift by around 5 percentage points, are reasonable, and more frequent rebalancing adds trading costs without clear benefits. Treat that as a general observation, not a rule for every portfolio.

How often should you rebalance

For most long-term investors, once a year is enough, such as at the start of the year or your birthday. Set a reminder. If you use bands, check quarterly and act only if an asset class is outside its range.

Other times to consider rebalancing:

  • After a large market move, if you check and find you are outside your bands
  • When your goals or time horizon change, such as getting within 10 years of retirement
  • After a big deposit, withdrawal or windfall
  • When changing jobs and rolling over a 401(k). See what is a 401(k).

Rebalancing and taxes

The way you rebalance can create a tax bill in a taxable brokerage account.

  • Selling investments that have gained triggers capital gains. Gains on assets held more than a year are taxed at long-term rates, and shorter holdings at ordinary rates. See long-term vs short-term capital gains.
  • Inside an IRA or 401(k), you can rebalance without current tax consequences, since transactions within the account are not taxed. See taxable vs tax-advantaged accounts.
  • Tax-efficient ways to rebalance in taxable accounts:
  • Direct new contributions to the underweight asset.
  • Direct dividends to the underweight asset instead of reinvesting everywhere.
  • Take withdrawals from the overweight asset.
  • Rebalance mainly in tax-advantaged accounts and let the taxable account follow.
  • Sell lots with losses or the highest cost basis, where you can choose the lots.
  • Consider donating appreciated shares to charity, if you give regularly.

Treat the whole set of accounts as one portfolio. You can hold bonds in an IRA and stocks in a taxable account, as long as the overall mix matches your target.

Rebalancing in a 401(k)

Most 401(k) plans let you do one of two things:

  1. Change future contributions to a different split.
  2. Reallocate the existing balance by exchanging funds. Many plans also offer an automatic rebalancing feature that resets your mix on a schedule.

Exchanges inside a 401(k) are generally not taxable events. If your plan has target-date funds, they rebalance and shift toward bonds as you age automatically. See target-date funds explained. Be careful about holding a target-date fund and other funds together, since the combination can distort your intended mix.

Does rebalancing improve returns?

Not reliably. Rebalancing sells assets that have done well and buys those that have lagged. In a long bull market for stocks, a rebalanced portfolio may earn less than one left alone, because you hold fewer stocks. In a downturn, rebalancing can cushion losses because you hold fewer stocks. The goal is consistent risk, not higher return.

A simple rebalancing routine

  1. Write your target mix and the acceptable range, for example 60% stocks plus or minus 5 points.
  2. Choose a check date once or twice a year.
  3. List every account and tally holdings by asset class. Include spouse accounts if you plan jointly.
  4. Compare actual to target. If inside the range, do nothing.
  5. If outside, use new contributions first. Then use tax-advantaged accounts. Use taxable accounts last.
  6. Record the change and set the next reminder.

Common mistakes

  1. Never rebalancing and ending up with an accidentally aggressive portfolio.
  2. Rebalancing too often, incurring taxes and trading costs.
  3. Ignoring taxes when selling in taxable accounts.
  4. Looking at each account separately instead of the total portfolio.
  5. Changing the target mix based on recent headlines rather than your goals.
  6. Duplicating a target-date fund with other funds.

Frequently asked questions

How often should I rebalance my portfolio?

Once a year is reasonable for most investors, or whenever an asset class drifts past a set band, such as 5 percentage points. More frequent rebalancing mainly adds cost.

Does rebalancing trigger taxes?

In a taxable account, selling investments at a gain can create capital gains tax. Rebalancing inside an IRA or 401(k) does not trigger tax at the time of the trade.

Do I need to rebalance a target-date fund?

No. Target-date funds rebalance automatically. See the fund's prospectus for how it adjusts over time.

Is it better to rebalance with new contributions?

It is often the cheapest way. Putting new money into the underweight asset moves you toward your target without selling.

What if my allocation is off but I do not want to sell?

You can leave it, but understand that you are holding more risk than planned. Using contributions or tax-advantaged accounts to adjust is an alternative.

Sources

Disclaimer: This page is for educational purposes only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Figures are estimates based on the assumptions shown. See our full disclaimer and editorial policy.

Free calculators for this topic

Keep reading