How to Choose a Health Insurance Plan

The cheapest premium is often not the cheapest plan. What you pay over a year depends on the premium, how much care you use, the deductible, copays, networks and the out-of-pocket maximum. This guide gives a total-cost method, a worked comparison and a checklist for open enrollment.

Updated October 13, 20263 min readBy FinTools USA Editorial TeamChecked against official sourcesHow we review
Key takeaways
  • Estimate total yearly cost as premiums plus what you expect to pay for care, up to the plan's out-of-pocket maximum.
  • Check the network and the drug list before price. A plan that excludes your doctor or medication costs more than it appears.
  • Low-use people may save with a high-deductible plan and an HSA. High-use people often do better with a lower deductible.
  • The out-of-pocket maximum is your worst-case cost for in-network covered care in a plan year, excluding premiums.
In this article
  1. The total-cost formula
  2. Worked comparison
  3. Plan types
  4. Check these before comparing prices
  5. HSA and FSA options
  6. Where to get coverage
  7. Open enrollment checklist
  8. Common mistakes
  9. Frequently asked questions
  10. Sources

For definitions of terms such as deductible, copay and coinsurance, see health insurance terms explained.

The total-cost formula

Yearly cost = 12 × monthly premium + the amount you pay for care you use

The care you pay for depends on the plan: you pay the full price until the deductible is met, then copays or coinsurance until you hit the out-of-pocket maximum. The best case for a plan is a year with little care (you pay only premiums). The worst case is premiums plus the out-of-pocket maximum.

Worked comparison

Three example plans for one person:

Plan A: Low deductible Plan B: High deductible Plan C: Middle
Annual premium (your share) $4,800 $2,400 $3,600
Deductible $500 $3,500 $1,700
Out-of-pocket max $4,500 $8,500 $6,500
Best case (no care) $4,800 $2,400 $3,600
Worst case $9,300 $10,900 $10,100

Plan B has the lowest premium and the best case, but it has the highest worst case. Plan A costs the most in a year with no care, but its worst case is much lower. These numbers are illustrative; real plans vary. List best case, worst case and an expected case based on your own use, then compare.

To estimate an expected case, list the care you expect: regular prescriptions, specialist visits, therapy, a planned procedure, a pregnancy. Add up the cost under each plan's rules. People with predictable, higher use should lean toward the plan with the lower worst case.

Plan types

Type Network Referrals Out-of-network
HMO Must use the network Often need a primary care referral Usually not covered except emergencies
PPO Broad network Usually not needed Partly covered at higher cost
EPO Network only Usually not needed Usually not covered
POS Mix of HMO and PPO features Referral often needed Partly covered
HDHP Any of the above structures Varies Varies

HMOs and EPOs often have lower premiums but less flexibility. PPOs cost more and offer more choice.

Check these before comparing prices

  1. Network: are your doctors, hospitals and pharmacies in-network? Use the plan's provider directory, then confirm by phone. Networks change.
  2. Drug formulary: are your medications covered, and in which tier? Check prior authorization rules.
  3. Referral rules for specialists.
  4. Coverage for services you use, such as mental health, physical therapy or fertility.
  5. Out-of-area coverage if you travel or have a child away at school.

HSA and FSA options

A plan that qualifies as a high-deductible health plan allows contributions to a health savings account. For 2026 the minimum deductible for an HSA-eligible plan is $1,700 for self-only coverage, and the HSA contribution limit is $4,400. If your employer contributes to the HSA, subtract that from the plan's cost. See HDHP and HSA guide and FSA vs HSA.

Where to get coverage

  • Employer plans: usually the lowest cost for the employee since the employer pays part. Compare the cost of adding family members.
  • Marketplace plans: for people without employer coverage. See ACA marketplace explained.
  • Medicare at 65. See Medicare basics.
  • Spouse's plan, COBRA, Medicaid, CHIP in applicable situations.

If your employer's coverage is considered unaffordable or inadequate under the rules, you may have options on the marketplace. Check the current criteria at HealthCare.gov.

Open enrollment checklist

  1. Gather last year's medical and pharmacy costs.
  2. List expected changes: surgery, pregnancy, new medications, a new dependent.
  3. Read each plan's summary of benefits and coverage.
  4. Check networks and the formulary.
  5. Compute best, expected and worst-case costs.
  6. Check HSA or FSA options and employer contributions.
  7. Decide who to cover. Compare adding a spouse to their own employer plan.
  8. Enroll before the deadline. Changes outside enrollment require a qualifying event.

Common mistakes

  1. Choosing by premium alone.
  2. Ignoring the out-of-pocket maximum.
  3. Not checking whether doctors are in-network.
  4. Forgetting prescription costs.
  5. Automatically renewing without reviewing changes.
  6. Under-using preventive care, which is usually covered without cost-sharing in ACA-compliant plans.

Frequently asked questions

Is a higher deductible plan cheaper?

Its premium is usually lower, but you pay more for care before coverage starts. It can cost less overall if you use little care.

What is the most important number to compare?

Total cost in a realistic year and the worst-case cost, which is premiums plus the out-of-pocket maximum.

Should I choose an HMO or a PPO?

An HMO may cost less if its network works for you. A PPO costs more but gives flexibility to see out-of-network providers.

Can I change plans mid-year?

Generally only during open enrollment or after a qualifying life event such as marriage, birth or loss of coverage.

Do out-of-network costs count toward the out-of-pocket maximum?

Often they do not, and out-of-network providers can bill more than the plan allows. Check the plan details.

Sources

Disclaimer: This page is for educational purposes only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Figures are estimates based on the assumptions shown. See our full disclaimer and editorial policy.

Free calculators for this topic

Keep reading