ETF vs Mutual Fund

ETFs and mutual funds both pool money to buy a basket of investments. They differ in how they are priced, how you buy them, what extra costs apply and how taxes can show up. Here is a plain comparison.

Updated October 13, 20265 min readBy FinTools USA Editorial TeamChecked against official sourcesHow we review
Key takeaways
  • A mutual fund is priced once a day at its net asset value (NAV). An ETF trades on an exchange throughout the day at a market price that can sit above or below NAV.
  • Both charge a yearly expense ratio. Mutual funds can add other fees, and ETF trades can involve broker commissions.
  • In a taxable account, ETFs often pass along fewer capital gains distributions. Inside a 401(k) or IRA, there is no tax difference between them.
  • Either can be an index fund or an actively managed fund. The strategy and the wrapper are separate choices.
In this article
  1. The comparison at a glance
  2. Pricing: NAV vs market price
  3. An example: investing $300
  4. Costs
  5. Taxes
  6. Index or active: the other choice
  7. Which fits which situation
  8. A simple way to decide
  9. Common mistakes
  10. Frequently asked questions
  11. Sources

Both ETFs (exchange-traded funds) and mutual funds are pooled investments: many investors put money in, and the fund buys stocks, bonds or other assets. You own shares of the fund rather than the individual holdings. The main differences are mechanical: how the price is set, where you buy and sell and how costs and taxes work. The SEC's investor education site and FINRA both describe these differences.

The comparison at a glance

Mutual fund ETF
Pricing Once per business day at NAV Market price throughout the trading day
Where you trade Directly from the fund company or through a broker On a stock exchange through a brokerage account
Price vs value You get the NAV Market price can be above (premium) or below (discount) NAV
Yearly cost Expense ratio Expense ratio
Other fees May have sales loads or purchase and redemption fees Brokerage commissions may apply
Minimum to start Some funds set a minimum Often the price of one share, or less with fractional shares
Taxes in a taxable account Gains can be distributed when the manager sells Often fewer distributions, since many ETFs use in-kind exchanges
Taxes in a 401(k) or IRA No difference No difference
Strategies Index or active Index or active

The SEC notes that retail investors can buy and sell ETF shares only in market transactions, meaning on a national stock exchange, so you need a brokerage account. Mutual funds are bought from the fund or through an intermediary and are redeemable with the fund.

Pricing: NAV vs market price

A fund's net asset value (NAV) is the value of everything it holds, minus its liabilities, divided by the number of shares. Mutual funds are required by law to price their shares at NAV each business day, typically after U.S. markets close. If you place an order in the morning, you will not know your price until the end of the day.

An ETF also has a NAV, but its shares trade like stocks. The price changes all day and is set by buyers and sellers. It usually stays close to NAV but can drift above or below, which FINRA describes as the market price deviating from the NAV. In calm markets for large ETFs the gap is usually small. In stressed markets, or for ETFs that hold thinly traded assets, it can widen.

An example: investing $300

This example uses made-up prices to show the mechanics. A mutual fund has a NAV of $48.60 a share. An ETF is priced at $120.00 a share.

Mutual fund ETF without fractional shares
Money invested $300 $300
Price per share $48.60 (NAV) $120.00 (market price)
Shares bought 6.173 2
Money actually invested $300 $240
Cash left over $0 $60

Mutual funds let you invest an exact dollar amount, because they can sell fractional shares. Some brokers now offer fractional ETF shares too, which removes the leftover cash. If your broker does not, a small automatic monthly investment can be awkward with an expensive ETF share. Check what your own broker offers.

Costs

The expense ratio

Both types charge an annual expense ratio, a percentage of your balance. The charge comes out of the fund's assets, so you never see a bill. FINRA calls it "Annual Fund Operating Expenses." On $50,000, a 0.10% ratio costs $50 a year and a 1.00% ratio costs $500. Over decades the difference compounds, as the guide to index funds shows.

Trading costs

Many brokers no longer charge commissions on ETF trades, but the policy varies. ETF buyers and sellers also pay the bid-ask spread, the gap between the buying and selling price. Mutual funds can carry sales loads (a commission paid to buy or sell) and other fees, and some funds charge a fee to sell shares held a short time. A no-load fund has no sales charge. Read the fee table in the prospectus.

Account fees

Some brokers charge an account fee or a minimum balance, and some mutual fund companies charge a small fee for low balances. Check them against your balance.

Taxes

In a tax-advantaged account such as a 401(k) or IRA, there is no tax difference between an ETF and a mutual fund, according to the SEC's investor education materials. Taxes depend on the account, not the fund type.

In a regular brokerage account, both pay taxable dividends and interest to you. The difference is in capital gains. When a mutual fund manager sells holdings that have grown, the fund must pass the realized gains to shareholders, and you owe tax on that distribution even if you did not sell any shares. ETFs often generate fewer capital gains distributions, because many ETFs buy and sell their holdings in in-kind exchanges instead of for cash, which typically means lower taxes. That is a tendency and not a guarantee. When you sell your own shares for more than you paid, you owe capital gains tax on your profit either way. The capital gains tax guide explains the rates.

Index or active: the other choice

An ETF is not automatically an index fund, and a mutual fund is not automatically active. Both can follow an index (passive) or rely on a manager's decisions (active). Many of the best-known index funds are available as both. The more important question is usually what the fund holds and what it costs. See index funds explained.

Which fits which situation

If you... One thing to consider
Invest the same dollar amount every month A mutual fund accepts exact amounts. Fractional ETF shares work too if offered.
Want to trade during the day Only ETFs trade intraday, though long-term investors rarely need to
Hold the fund in a 401(k) Your plan's menu decides what is available
Invest in a taxable account Check the fund's history of capital gains distributions
Have a small starting balance Compare minimums and fractional share options
Want the lowest cost for a given index Compare expense ratios, spreads and loads

A simple way to decide

  1. Pick the investments first. Decide the asset mix and the index or strategy.
  2. Check what your account offers. A 401(k) menu may include only mutual funds. A brokerage account offers both.
  3. Compare total costs: expense ratio, loads, commissions and spreads.
  4. Consider taxes if the account is taxable.
  5. Choose the one that is easier to keep doing. Regular, automatic investing beats a clever choice you abandon.

Common mistakes

  1. Choosing by wrapper instead of holdings. Two ETFs can have very different risks.
  2. Ignoring the spread on thinly traded ETFs.
  3. Trading too often. Frequent trades add costs and, in taxable accounts, taxes.
  4. Buying a mutual fund with a load without comparing a no-load option.
  5. Assuming an ETF is always more tax-efficient. The tendency varies by fund.
  6. Forgetting that NAV is set after the close, so mutual fund orders do not execute at the morning price.
Investment CalculatorTest different monthly amounts, returns and costs.
Open the calculator

Frequently asked questions

Is an ETF better than a mutual fund?

Neither is better for everyone. ETFs offer intraday trading and often fewer capital gains distributions. Mutual funds are convenient for exact-dollar investing and are common in retirement plans.

Do ETFs have lower fees?

Not always. Both charge an expense ratio. Compare each fund's ratio, plus loads and commissions.

Are ETFs safer than mutual funds?

No. Safety depends on what the fund holds, not on the type of wrapper.

Can I hold ETFs in my 401(k)?

Only if your plan offers them. Many plans offer mutual funds, and your IRA at a brokerage can hold ETFs.

Which is more tax-efficient?

ETFs often distribute fewer capital gains, but inside a 401(k) or IRA there is no difference.

Sources

Disclaimer: This page is for educational purposes only and is not financial, tax or legal advice. Figures are estimates based on the assumptions shown. See our full disclaimer and editorial policy.

Free calculators for this topic

Keep reading